Mom's Pantry is your next spot for delicious and fresh homemade salads. Located just inside the market entrance, we have over 40 types of salad. From chicken and potato salad to fruit salad and pudding, we can fill your fridge with tasty delights. 


85% of our salads are made on site with home style recipes. We also offer chicken salads that are gluten free and made with antibiotic free chickens that are farm raised in Ohio!

Come in today and ask about our discount pricing of large orders for your next catered event. Currently offering whole trays and dessert trays for $28, please call ahead.

Looking for a deal? Check out our coupons by clicking here!

Stop by and pick up a delicious, organic chicken salad!


  • Redskin Potato Salad $4.95/lb

  • *Philly Potato Salad $4.15/lb

  • *Lancaster County Potato Salad $4.15/lb

  • *Macaroni Salads $3.89/lb

  • *Coleslaw and Pepper Cabbage $3.89/lb

  • *Cucumber & Onion Salad $3.89/lb

  • *Broccoli and Cauliflower Salad $5.25/lb

  • *Pasta Salad $4.69/lb

  • *Chicken Pot-Pie $4.89/lb

  • Macaroni and Cheese $4.35/lb

  • Meatballs $5.49/lb

  • Baked Beans $4.59/lb

  • Baked Limas $4.59/lb

  • Pork Barbecue $6.49/lb

  • *Ham Salad $7.25/lb

  • *Chicken Salad $7.95/lb

  • *Tuna Salad $8.25/lb

  • *Pickled Beets $4.35/lb

  • *Pickled Eggs (Available by 6 or 12)

  • *Deviled Eggs (Available by 6,12 or 24)

  • Shrimp Salad $10.89/lb

  • Seafood Salad $10.89/lb

  • *Chicken Corn Noodle Soup $4.35/lb

  • Chicken Croquettes 

  • Crab Cakes

Prices subject to change.

Fruit Salad & Desserts

  • *Triple Berry Cobbler $5.49/lb

  • *Peach Cobbler $5.49/lb

  • *Bread Pudding $5.49/lb

  • Egg Custard $4.85/lb

  • Rice Pudding $4.85/lb

  • *Banana Pudding $5.49/lb

  • *Strawberry Delight $5.49/lb

  • *Dutch Delight $4.99/lb

  • *Chocolate Eclair Pudding $5.49/lb

  • *Dirt Pudding $5.49/lb

  • *Ice Cream Pudding $5.49/lb

  • *Watergate Salad $4.29/lb

  • *Fruit Salad $4.25/lb

*Made on Site

Seasonal Items

  • Triple Berry Cobbler

  • Apple Crisp

  • Pumpkin Torte

  • Pumpkin Custard

  • Pumpkin Bread Pudding

  • Blueberry Delight

  • Tomato Salad